diff: fix interaction between the "-s" option and other options

Sergey Organov noticed and reported "--patch --no-patch --raw"
behaves differently from just "--raw".  It turns out that there are
a few interesting bugs in the implementation and documentation.

 * First, the documentation for "--no-patch" was unclear that it
   could be read to mean "--no-patch" countermands an earlier
   "--patch" but not other things.  The intention of "--no-patch"
   ever since it was introduced at d09cd15d (diff: allow --no-patch
   as synonym for -s, 2013-07-16) was to serve as a synonym for
   "-s", so "--raw --patch --no-patch" should have produced no
   output, but it can be (mis)read to allow showing only "--raw"
   output.

 * Then the interaction between "-s" and other format options were
   poorly implemented.  Modern versions of Git uses one bit each to
   represent formatting options like "--patch", "--stat" in a single
   output_format word, but for historical reasons, "-s" also is
   represented as another bit in the same word.  This allows two
   interesting bugs to happen, and we have both X-<.

   (1) After setting a format bit, then setting NO_OUTPUT with "-s",
       the code to process another "--<format>" option drops the
       NO_OUTPUT bit to allow output to be shown again.  However,
       the code to handle "-s" only set NO_OUTPUT without unsetting
       format bits set earlier, so the earlier format bit got
       revealed upon seeing the second "--<format>" option.  This is
       the problem Sergey observed.

   (2) After setting NO_OUTPUT with "-s", code to process
       "--<format>" option can forget to unset NO_OUTPUT, leaving
       the command still silent.

It is tempting to change the meaning of "--no-patch" to mean
"disable only the patch format output" and reimplement "-s" as "not
showing anything", but it would be an end-user visible change in
behavior.  Let's fix the interactions of these bits to first make
"-s" work as intended.

The fix is conceptually very simple.

 * Whenever we set DIFF_FORMAT_FOO because we saw the "--foo"
   option (e.g. DIFF_FORMAT_RAW is set when the "--raw" option is
   given), we make sure we drop DIFF_FORMAT_NO_OUTPUT.  We forgot to
   do so in some of the options and caused (2) above.

 * When processing "-s" option, we should not just set
   DIFF_FORMAT_NO_OUTPUT bit, but clear other DIFF_FORMAT_* bits.
   We didn't do so and retained format bits set by options
   previously seen, causing (1) above.

It is even more tempting to lose NO_OUTPUT bit and instead take
output_format word being 0 as its replacement, but that would break
the mechanism "git show" uses to default to "--patch" output, where
the distinction between telling the command to be silent with "-s"
and having no output format specified on the command line matters,
and an explicit output format given on the command line should not
be "combined" with the default "--patch" format.

So, while we cannot lose the NO_OUTPUT bit, as a follow-up work, we
may want to replace it with OPTION_GIVEN bit, and

 * make "--patch", "--raw", etc. set DIFF_FORMAT_$format bit and
   DIFF_FORMAT_OPTION_GIVEN bit on for each format.  "--no-raw",
   etc. will set off DIFF_FORMAT_$format bit but still record the
   fact that we saw an option from the command line by setting
   DIFF_FORMAT_OPTION_GIVEN bit.

 * make "-s" (and its synonym "--no-patch") clear all other bits
   and set only the DIFF_FORMAT_OPTION_GIVEN bit on.

which I suspect would make the code much cleaner without breaking
any end-user expectations.

Once that is in place, transitioning "--no-patch" to mean the
counterpart of "--patch", just like "--no-raw" only defeats an
earlier "--raw", would be quite simple at the code level.  The
social cost of migrating the end-user expectations might be too
great for it to be worth, but at least the "GIVEN" bit clean-up
alone may be worth it.

Signed-off-by: Junio C Hamano <gitster@pobox.com>

1 files changed, 5 insertions, 2 deletions

diff --git a/Documentation/diff-options.txt b/Documentation/diff-options.txt
index 3674ac48e9..7d5bb65a49 100644
--- a/Documentation/diff-options.txt
+++ b/Documentation/diff-options.txt
@@ -29,8 +29,11 @@ endif::git-diff[]
 
 -s::
 --no-patch::
-	Suppress diff output. Useful for commands like `git show` that
-	show the patch by default, or to cancel the effect of `--patch`.
+	Suppress all output from the diff machinery.  Useful for
+	commands like `git show` that show the patch by default to
+	squelch their output, or to cancel the effect of options like
+	`--patch`, `--stat` earlier on the command line in an alias.
+
 endif::git-format-patch[]
 
 ifdef::git-log[]